I thought it only appropriate to kick off the holiday shopping season and make my first entry since Black Friday about the most ridiculously consumerist idea for a social network ever. The site is called Metrofunk.com and the premise is simple, an invite only social network for ‘trendsetters’. The premise raises three questions right off the bat. The first is, why does there need to be yet another social network that has no additional functionality to a Facebook or a MySpace. Second, and peripherally related, don’t the people who this service purports to serve, nightclub promoters, musicians, fashion designers, and film producers, and others already use MySpace to collect their fans and promote themselves? The final question is, why should it be invite only?
Their mission in their owns words is to:
1. give trend-followers a central place to gather information on trends and content pertaining to the world of nightlife events, fashion, music, and film and 2. To empower the trendsetters by providing them with online tools, resources, and a focused networking medium to expose and fulfill their product offerings.
Again, why is this unique? By making it invite only aren’t they just stiffling the promotion mission and alienating potential fans that could more easily be obtained through something like MySpace?
Even their homepage screams, this is a place or people who think they are better than everyone else, to make themselves feel like they are.
I mean take a look at that, it attempts to look vogue and sheik like the exclusive nightclub. While exclusivity may be good in theory to build buzz, its not the idea which the Web 2.0 is based around, openness and virality. By making it closed, how do they think they are going to make money? Ad revenue is measured in CPM, or cost per thousand. Having a necessarily small user base makes the website necessarily small. Now, the argument may be made that these users will be more valuable per CPM because they are the ‘trendy’ ones. But I don’t think that that is the way that advertisers will see it.
Therefore, this project seems doomed to fail, and rightly so, as the title of this post stated, this is exactly what ‘trendy’ people do not need. It seems to amount to nothing more than a clique that makes ‘trendy’ people feel better about themselves, with no real social utility that can’t be found elsewhere, and a user base that won’t expand very much if the site desires to keep itself exclusive.
Popularity: 15% [?]
2 users commented in " Review: Metrofunk.com, Exactly What Pretentious People Don’t Need a Reason to Feel More Pretentious "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackI think pretentious people will be pretentious regardless of whether or not there is some social network to facilitate that mentality. But i dont think that is the point of the site. Facebook and myspace has virtually become a spam heaven for internet marketers and direct marketing groups alike, metrofunk seems to be making a stand against going that way. I actually HAVE been invited to the site during an early stage and it really is quite different than anything that is out there. The site seems to be more focused on real content produced by trendsetters rather than merely on the social networking aspect of things. Dunno, i myself am curious to see how they end up doing.
-kev
Unless Paris and Nicole are on the site, it’s certainly not “trendsetting.”
Leave A Reply